New Layout: Yea or Nay?

I originally changed to the green just in the spirit of St. Patty's Day, being of mostly Irish descent. But I kinda dig it, especially compared to the last layout.

But what do you think? Keep the new one? Go back to the old? Scrap 'em both to pick something else?

(Management reserves the right to disregard the winning choice if he...ahem...they feel like it)